Skip to content
Latest
F1Statement

Leclerc says Brazil penalty for Lawson contact was a bit harsh

Charles Leclerc believes his five-second penalty in Brazil was too severe, insisting that his contact with Liam Lawson on the penultimate lap was simply part of racing.

· 3 min read

Charles Leclerc
Charles Leclerc · Photo: Jason Puddephatt · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

In brief

  • Leclerc was given a five-second penalty for contact with Lawson, dropping him from seventh to eighth.
  • The stewards judged the contact minor but with an obvious sporting consequence; the wet conditions kept the penalty at five seconds instead of ten.
  • Leclerc called the decision “a bit harsh”, while Norris described the move as “just racing”.

What happened at Interlagos?

On the penultimate lap of the Brazilian Grand Prix, Charles Leclerc went down the inside at Turn 12, Juncao, and tapped the left rear of Liam Lawson's car. Five corners later, through the Senna S, he passed the Racing Bulls driver. GPFans refers to three corners, while the stewards' reasoning says five.

After the race the stewards handed Leclerc a five-second time penalty. He dropped from seventh to eighth, and Lawson was classified seventh.

According to the decision quoted by PlanetF1, the contact was minor. Lawson, however, said it had damaged his left rear rim and let Leclerc get closer. Under the Driving Standards Guidelines, Lawson had the right to the corner, so it was up to Leclerc to avoid a collision. The stewards saw an “obvious sporting consequence”, as the touch disrupted Lawson and allowed Leclerc to pull alongside. The wet conditions and the minor nature of the contact were why they chose five seconds rather than ten.

Leclerc: “a bit harsh”

Ahead of the Las Vegas Grand Prix, Leclerc said that, judged on Brazil alone, the move was part of racing, particularly in those conditions. He knew it could end in a slight touch, but not in anything worse. Motorsport.com reports that he also accepted the stewards had a difficult decision to make.

“I don't think there's one very wrong or very right decision, but I do believe that it didn't deserve the penalty.” – Charles Leclerc

Lando Norris called the move “just racing” on a Twitch stream after the race. GPFans says Max Verstappen reacted in the cool-down room with “rubbing is racing”.

Background: Mexico and the standings

It was Leclerc's second five-second penalty in consecutive races. In Mexico he went off the track and gained an advantage while fighting team-mate Lewis Hamilton for the lead on the opening lap, and he finished fourth. PlanetF1 says neither Ferrari made Turn 4, which let Verstappen through. Hamilton was furious, and the row carried into Brazil before team boss Fred Vasseur held talks with his drivers. Looking at the two weekends together, Leclerc said Brazil was “probably the five seconds that I didn't get in Mexico”.

In the drivers' standings Leclerc is fifth on 249 points, 12 behind Hamilton (261) and 3 ahead of sixth-placed Lando Norris (246). Lawson has 89 points and, after 55 starts, no podium. Leclerc has made 193 starts, with 9 wins and 56 podiums.

What does it mean?

The decision does not change the order between the teams. Ferrari are second on 510 points, 95 clear of third-placed Red Bull. Within the drivers' table, however, the gaps are tight, so every lost position counts in the internal fight with Hamilton and in keeping Norris behind.

Las Vegas opens the triple-header that ends the season, so the question for Leclerc is how to get through the weekend with clean fights and no penalties.

5 sec
Leclerc's time penalty at the Brazilian GP
12 points
Leclerc's deficit to Hamilton in the drivers' standings
95 points
Ferrari's lead over third-placed Red Bull
8th
Leclerc's final classification in Brazil

Paddox poll

Was the five-second penalty for Leclerc fair?

Charles LeclercLiam LawsonBrazil NagydíjFerrariidőbüntetésFormula–1

Enjoyed it? Share it!

Comments

Comments are reviewed by automated moderation every four hours; anyone can report unlawful content. Rules

Leclerc calls Brazil penalty for Lawson contact harsh – Paddox